Aries: chocolate lava cake
Taurus: brownies
Gemini: funfetti cupcakes
Cancer: apple pie
Leo: creme brulee
Virgo: mint ice cream
Libra: pavlova
Scorpio: tiramisu
Sagittarius: blueberry tart
Capricorn: cheese cake
Aquarius: key lime pie
Pisces: strawberry shortcake (made me think of Erza..)