After the Echo Cave, everyone finds the Wonderlandians at the Lost Boys campsite after the natives helped them escape. It's also where Piper is reunited with his parents. Everyone soon finds out the meaning behind the abduction of the Wonderlandians. Those from Wonderland are born with Wonder Magic which is what makes them different from others. And Pan wants to use their Wonder Magic to become more powerful. After a while, when Pan is taunting Piper, Piper snaps and reveals to everyone his biggest fear- losing his friends outside of Neverland.

At first, not being able to age sounded cool, but after a while, it started to take a toll on the residents of Neverland. Even Peter Pan admits that he would like to grow up and even die naturally. They've thought about moving out of Neverland, but Neverland is their home, they just wished that there was a way to make time move in Neverland so that everyone can age naturally.

Fast forward to when Pan sucks out the Wonder Magic from the Wonderlandians, making them appear to be dead. When Mira, Raven, and Apple go after Pan, he appears and has them bound to the Tree of Regret, a tree that will never release a person who is filled with regret. But despite admitting that she cast the Dark Curse, Mira has no regret over it because it gave her her family back and a new set of friends, freeing her and allowing her to steal Pan's heart which she uses to return the Wonder Magic back to the Wonderlandians.

But when they return to Storybrooke, Chase discovers that Pan is still around and that he had swapped bodies with Alistair when they were aboard Jane's ship, meaning that the real Alistair is trapped in Pandora's Box. But even after their bodies are returned, Pan is still a threat. But little did Pan know that Piper already had a plan. When they're faced with each other the next day where Pan has threatened to kill Piper so that Pan will live on, Piper points out that Pan doesn't have his shadow, and neither does he because he sent his shadow to hide something important.

At that moment, Piper's shadow appears and gives him Carey's dagger which he uses to stab his clone into extinction. Even though Pan may be gone, Piper knows that Pan will always be inside him because he was created out of fear. But now that Pan is out of the way, Alistair reveals that he may know a way to make time move in Neverland. After all, Time is his father. And it was thanks to Time that he was able to make time move in Neverland, meaning that they can still live there and still grow up. Even though the thought of growing old sounds a bit scary, the residents of Neverland are happy to do so. Besides, having to stay young for many years has gotten boring. And as long as there's an heir to the Pan line, Neverland will never die.

As Peter Pan once said: "To die would be an awfully big adventure." He knows when it's his time to die, he will soon be reunited with his beloved family and friends.

After all of that, everyone celebrates at a nightclub where Piper and Jane share their first kiss. And the next day, the Neverlandians say goodbye to their friends before setting sail back to Neverland, their new Neverland. Now that everyone is able to grow up in Neverland, Piper is reunited with his uncles John and Micheal and is now married to Jane. They soon have a daughter who they named Margaret-Anne Pan and a son named Peter James Pan. And even though they live in Neverland, they will always have another home in England.

__________

During the Neverland story, Jane wasn't the only pirate who was introduced. After losing her hand, Jane went on a mission to find a rare diamond called the Never Diamond, a diamond that can be ground up into blue fairy dust which has multiple and powerful effects. During her journey, she stopped in a realm called Bristol Channel on the West English Coast where she meets another female pirate, Marissa Silver, daughter of Long John Silver. With her long curly light brown hair and innocent look, Marissa is a beauty among the other pirates. Jane also meets Christopher Hawkins, son of Jim Hawkins and a caretaker at his family's Inn, Admiral Benbow. When she hears that the inn might get closed down due to lack of currency, she gives Chris her rings that should pay the bills before she sets sail.

Like his father, Chris loves a good adventure but has yet to visit Treasure Island. During that time, Jim Hawkins was on a business trip when he sends Chris a letter saying that Blackbeard is searching for the Never Diamon which is located on Treasure Island. If Blackbeard gets his hands on that diamond, bad things will happen. He tells his son that he still has the map to Treasure Island and that Chris can use it to find the Never Diamond before Blackbeard does. However, Marissa discovers the map and declares that she wants to join Chris. Even though Chris doesn't trust Marissa because she's a pirate, Chris allows her to join him out of fear and if they find any more treasure, she must split it with him.

The two board Marissa's ship, the Pieces of Eight, and set sail towards Treasure Island. Along the way, the two talk and form a bond they never thought they would have. But one night, they meet a ghost pirate named Vandala Doubloon. She warns them to be careful on Treasure Island since it's changed over the years and has become dangerous. She even adds that many people have gone to the island but not many have returned. Some say the island is booby-trapped and filled with savages who will kill anyone. But that wasn't going to stop Chris from finding the Never Diamond.