Truth or Dare - Part 1

This chapter takes place after 3x08, although in this Marty has already returned. During a game of Truth or Dare, feelings are revealed and Cyrus has a decision to make.


Cyrus' POV


So Buffy had persuaded me to go to a sleepover at Jonah's house. Andi, Marty and TJ were also going to be there. As much as I love my friends, there are times when I wish we didn't have to do sleepovers.


When I arrived at Jonah's house, I was greeted by the human sunbeam himself.


Jonah: Cy-guy, you made it!


Me: Hi Jonah, are the other's here yet?


Jonah: Yeah, they are upstairs in my bedroom.


Me: Cool


I followed Jonah as he walked up to his room. When we entered, I was surprised at how large his room was. I looked to see the others sitting on the floor in a circle, so Jonah and I joined them. I looked at TJ, and was happy to see him.


TJ: Yo underdog.


Me: Hi not so scary basketball guy.


Before we could say anything else, the rest of the group wanted to get on with the evening. I admit it was slightly disappointing that I couldn't continue the conversation.


Buffy: So, what are we going to do?


Andi: Why don't we play truth or dare?


Jonah: That's a great idea.


Marty: Let's get started. Buffy, truth or dare?


Buffy: Dare.


Marty: I dare you to kiss me.


We had all been waiting for this moment for quite  a while. I was aware that Buffy really liked Marty, as much as she would deny it, but we could all see through that.


Buffy: Hmm.


Andi: Oh stop stalling Buffy, we all know that you want this.


Marty: Look, you don't have--


Before Marty could finish, Buffy leaned in and kissed him. We all cheered as we knew they both enjoyed it.


Marty: Wow, that was great!


Buffy: It was wasn't it?


After seeing that, I was intrigued to know what my truth or dare was going to be.


Jonah POV


I was happy that I had invited all of my friends over, but I had noticed something. Cyrus and TJ were looking at each other with major heart eyes. I didn't have time to think much about it as it was now my turn.


Buffy: Jonah truth or dare?


Me: Dare.


Buffy: I dare you to tell the person you love that you love them.


Now I know what you're thinking. This was going to be fairly easy, I would tell Andi I loved her, right? Well I suddenly found myself feeling something new. I had been feeling like a third wheel, and then it hit me. I was jealous, of TJ.


Me: Do I... have to?


Buffy: Yes, it's a dare.


TJ: No backing out now.


Me: Can I please wait until after the next person's turn before I say?


Cyrus: But why?


Me: Because there is something I need to know first.


Andi: I guess we could allow that, but only once.


Me: Docious.


I knew that it was a long shot, but this was something I knew that I just had to do. It was now or never and even though the feelings were new, I wanted some clarification before I went through with my dare.


Me: So Cyrus, truth or dare?


Cyrus: Truth


I was dreading having to ask this question, because I was certain of the answer and also I believed everyone would hate me for asking it.


Me: Are you in love with TJ?


My heart was pounding really loudly, and I knew everyone was staring at me as if I was some sort of idiot. But I just  had to know the answer.


Cyrus POV


My hands were becoming increasingly sweaty. I had never been asked that question before and I was not sure of the answer, but I tried my best to be accurate.


Me: Um... I'm not sure.


I noticed that TJ looked a little disappointed, but Jonah was confused more than anything. I was feeling like I had made the situation worse.


Jonah: Really?


Me: Yes really Jonah.


Jonah: Okay. I guess I'll do my dare now.


Me: What do you mean?


Jonah: Well, the thing is, I lo-love you Cy-Cyrus.


This will have a part 2 which will be uploaded soon.


How do you think Cyrus will react?

Comment