Guys:
Daniel Park- He chose a butterfly because it was soft enough to double as a pillow, and it reminds him of how much he has changed and wants to improve.

Jay Hong- He won you a lucky cat plushy to bring you good luck after you lost all your money trying to win it yourself.

Vasco- He thought it was a real dog from far away and won it, but gave it to you when he found out it was just a statue.

Jace Park-  Jace let you pick the prize and wasn't surprised when you picked the monkey plush to go home with. It was the first of many prizes you would win that night.

Gun Jong-  Since his nickname for you is rabbit and you call him bee he thought this was perfect.

Goo Joon- Your crocodile tears were the reason you two ever began to deal with one another, so it was a perfect fit.

Eli Jang- a chameleon changes just like Eli is always trying to do with your hairstyle.

Kouji-  You were someone who's IQ matches his, and you like black so he got you a raven because he figured you would think it was cool. 

Girls:
Crystal Choi- Goldfish are supposed to be good luck, and since you went to the fair rather than staying home to study for finals you'd be needing it.

Zoe Park-  Zoe is very good at the fair games and wound up winning you two plushies.  Sloths are slow and in no rush just like you.

Joy Hong-  You and Joy had been at a photoshoot before going to the fair.  The photographer had chosen a swan lake theme so Joy knew what prize she wanted to win you.

Mira Kim-  She always liked how smart you are so she got you an owl keychain plush.

Yui Kim-  You're cute and this was the cutest plushy the stand had so she thought it fit you well.