You Kill:

Aries: Lost Silver

Taurus: Smile Dog

Gemini: Clockwork

Cancer: The Puppeteer

Leo: BEN Drowned

Virgo: Jeff The Killer

Libra: Masky

Scorpio: Eyeless Jack

Sagittarius: Nina The Killer

Capricorn: Sally Williams

Aquarius: Zalgo

Pisces: Slenderman