Kid the Phantom Thief & Lunar Phase & Recluse x Aesop
/////SMUT/////
Foursome real ???? Never even wrote a threesome yet ???
_____
I KNOW IT LOOKS SUS AF BUT THIS WAS BORN BC OF THE ELISOP SERVER, IM NOT THE CULPRIT.
Also woah, sure went through some shit for the past week, everything was such a mess and I even got my discord acc hacked lmao /lh
_____
It was an absolutely normal day like any other.
Aesop had woken up next to Eli that morning and had some pain around the area of his pelvis for some reason but after a hot shower and some stretching, he felt pretty good, a little lingering fatigue excluded. He then pulled the fierce night owl out of its nest to force it to come and have their breakfast together to start their day.
Once again, the embalmer had quite a few games scheduled. He would be lying if he said he didn't find it tiring to have to spend his days running around with no real purpose since they were stuck in this mansion. However, the seer's company somehow managed to replenish his energy and encourage him to cooperate with the other survivors.
From the list this time, it looked like he only had three games and the last one would be in the early afternoon with Eli. It was a good thing that luck was smiling at him on this occasion, he would finally be able to spend a fairly peaceful day and enjoy the good weather, not to mention that it was also the only match for the seer and he could therefore keep him company.
So, after having finished his first two games quickly with clean wins, the third one finally came. Aesop arrived about fifteen minutes before the start of the match as he preferred to be early to prepare himself mentally and physically for what was to come. It wasn't the first time and he was quite used to it by now but the anxiety was still permanent despite everything. Even if it meant arriving at almost the same time as those assigned to the previous match, his mind was more relaxed this way.
Well, not surprisingly, Aesop was not the first to arrive at this moment. This was because Eli was already sitting in a chair when he arrived and was stroking Brooke's feathers as he waited. The man had apparently decided to pull out one of the suits the owner of the mansion had given him, now wearing a long beige coat and his hair in full view.
His attention was then drawn to the embalmer as he heard the sound of his footsteps and he looked up and gave the male a charming smile. Aesop blushed slightly, his mask fortunately hiding the reddish tint of his cheeks, Eli probably knew that he would arrive early and as usual, the seer could not leave his lover unattended.
The embalmer cleared his throat when he realized that he had stayed a few seconds too long to stare at the dark-haired man and approached the table where the latter was before taking a seat beside him. Eli's head snapped back to his owl at this point, his hand coming to scratch behind the animal's ear.
"How's your body?" he asked bluntly.
"F-Fine."
Damn Eli Clark, he thought. Unlike at the beginning of their relationship, if it wasn't for his immunity, which he'd forged by repeatedly hearing the seer's somewhat shameless remarks, Aesop would have been two steps away from having a stroke.
The fortune teller sensed his partner's agitation and let out a weak laugh.
Eli and Aesop exchanged a few more words after that and the rest of their teammates soon showed up a few moments later.
The atmosphere was a bit more agitated due to the presence of Mike Morton, also known as the acrobat, a young blond guy who was constantly euphoric. He wasn't really the kind of person the embalmer could get along with to be honest, the acrobat was just too loud and boisterous for him, there was that but also, for some reason he ignored, his instinct told him to be wary of the man.
It was strange but it wasn't nonsense. Mike had seemed a little too comfortable since arriving at the mansion, while most had had trouble adjusting to the new environment, the blond was just too laid back. Well, it's not like they were close or anything in any case so he preferred to ignore the male's suspicious behavior.
Time passed and the game time was only one more tick of the clock away when Aesop was suddenly startled by shouts coming from Mike's side. He was so lost in thought that he hadn't even noticed the fact that the acrobat had accidentally thrown one of his balls in the wrong direction and knowing that they were explosive, both the blond and the other survivor instinctively got up and moved away from the table to avoid being the victim of a terrible accident while Eli and Aesop remained seated in their chairs.
"Watch out!" the blond man shouted.
The embalmer slowly looked up to see a juggling ball coming in his direction but before it could reach him, his vision suddenly darkened and when he opened his eyes again, he was at Sacred Heart Hospital. He breathed a sigh of relief after the unexpected rush of adrenaline and quickly pulled himself together to focus on the game.
He placed his coffin behind the abandoned shack to hide it and went to decode the cipher a little further away. He began to decode quietly, his attention distracted for a moment when he recognized Brooke flying over his head in a circle. He smiled faintly as he saw her leave and continued to decode, but it didn't last very long when he felt the bird's presence again. Hm? Had Eli made a mistake?
Aesop looked up but was surprised to see a different Brooke flying above him. Compared to the first one he had seen with a bandage over her eye, this one was white as snow with a sparkling blue eye. The embalmer then stopped decoding and took a step back, raising an eyebrow as he watched the second Brooke leave. The young man was visibly confused, but unfortunately he was not out of the woods yet when a dove came circling around him this time.
Okay, something was definitely strange about this game.
The embalmer looked at his monitor with mild concern, his heart beating a little faster than usual. Then, his eyes widened when he saw the name of the seer three times.
There were three Eli in the game?!
How was that possible? Clones? Another magic trick from that cursed manor?
He blinked several times to make sure he wasn't dreaming, but the shrill screech of one of the owls brought him back to earth. One of the Eli had just used Brooke. He was still in the game.
Aesop clicked his tongue and went back to decoding his cipher before leaving for another. The rest of the match went smoothly with a landslide victory, the hunter was surely frustrated by now having been manhandled by three seers. Unfortunately, since the other three were too busy distracting the hunter, the embalmer hadn't had a chance to get a glimpse of them.
Since this was some sort of mistake, the two extra Eli would probably be gone by the end of the game.
However, as he returned to the waiting room to wait for Eli, Aesop froze when he saw three silhouettes appear. The first was that of the Eli he had originally seen with the outfit called Recluse but beside him was another man with identical features who wore a white robe and veil that he had seen the seer wear once before, Lunar Phase. There was still a third male wearing a top hat and some sort of rather extravagant costume with a cape and also the owner of the dove he had seen during the game.
"E-Eli-?" he called.
Aesop gasped as the three men turned to face him, feeling as if he was surrounded. What kind of situation was this?
Each of them were different and yet possessed the same name and face.
Suddenly, Recluse approached him with the other two, and Aesop instinctively took a step back seeing three replicas of his lover so close. It was both incredible and terrifying.
"It's all right, Aesop. They're harmless." he reassured.
Lunar Phase nodded with a smile and the embalmer looked at each of them in turn, they were all Eli... Nothing could happen to him then...? Probably.
"That's pretty... disconcerting. Also, is this one really you? This is the first time I've seen him and Brooke is... a dove."
The man in the white suit let out a laugh before bowing and giving the embalmer a wink.
"I'm also Eli, but you can call me Kid to make things easier."
"I see..."
Recluse's eyes were hidden by his blindfold, but it was easy to tell that he rolled his eyes at Kid's flirtatious behavior. For a second, if he wasn't so confused by the situation, Aesop would have found the way the three Eli's interacted with themselves rather entertaining.
"So... Are they going to be here long...?" he asked hesitantly. It wasn't that he didn't like the seer, but one Eli was more than enough for him.
"I don't know... But I guess right now we don't have much of a choice." replied Recluse.
"Why don't we just enjoy the present for today?" then offered Lunar Phase.
"Oh, that's a good idea!" exclaimed Kid.
And so, still not quite understanding how they got there. Aesop found himself spending a more eventful afternoon than expected with the three Eli's. The other survivors were just as surprised as he was to see the three men, some giving them curious looks while others had come to them to converse.
From the embalmer's side, this was quite a peculiar experience and he couldn't really find words to describe what he was feeling. Each Eli was generally the same, but as he paid attention to some details, he noticed that they had some differences.
Clearly, Kid was more open and playful than the other two, surprising him with magic tricks that even Servais couldn't reproduce. Lunar Phase was surely the calmest of all and gave off an even more mysterious aura than the seer would usually do. Finally, Recluse was supposed to be the original Eli since he was there before the game even started but Aesop had the feeling that he was a tad different too, perhaps more scowling than usual.
"May I ask why the three of you are in my room...?"
The day had gone smoothly and Aesop thought it would stay that way, but he was proven wrong when the three Eli came crashing into his room. Apparently, one bed was only big enough for two people at most, but since there were more of them, their solution was to send one to the embalmer.
However, it seemed that the three seers were unable to agree on the matter...
"I was here first so you can go back to our room." Recluse stated.
"Excuse me!?"
Kid and Recluse began to argue again in the embalmer's room and Aesop simply watched them proceed without knowing where to stand.
Seeing the uncomfortable position the embalmer was in, Lunar Phase suddenly approached him, running a delicate hand over his cheek, their faces extremely close to one another.
"Aesop, which one of us do you want...?" he whispered before pressing his lips to his tenderly.
The embalmer blushed at the unexpected kiss but returned his embrace, placing his hand on his and squinting his eyes.
"Hey, aren't you forgetting someone here?" Kid's irritated voice suddenly interrupted them.
"You're both so focused on yourselves that you're not even bothering asking for his opinion."
"Nonsense," Kid spatted before grabbing Aesop's wrist and pulling him so as to make the embalmer bump into his chest, "We already know that the answer is me, right?"
Recluse suddenly frowned at those words and came closer too, putting his hands on the embalmer's shoulders and trying to get him away from Kid.
"Get your hands off him, can't you see that you're making him uncomfortable?" he replied.
Aesop was pretty calm until now but having so many people in his room truly started to push him to the edge and he finally had enough.
"Won't all of you shut up for a second?!"
He used both of his hands to shove the two men away but he may have used slightly too much strength when he saw Kid about to fall backwards on the bed. However, the latter only smirked while pulling on his wrist, thus making the embalmer stumble, now on top of him with Kid's hands firmly on his waist.
"W-What are you doing..."
"Having some fun I guess." he answered teasingly.
"This is rather awkward than funny..." he said, flustered.
"Why so? Would you be embarrassed if I did something indecent to you in front of the others?" he purred into his ear.
"You wouldn't dare..."
Aesop glanced at Recluse and Lunar Phase who seemed to be weirdly calm all of a sudden, making him even more conscious of the position he was in and blushing even more. Kid only laughed at that and suddenly lifted his knee between the embalmer's thighs as he slipped his hand under his shirt to touch his chest, pinching one of his nipples with his gloved hand.
"I'm not really the soft type." he chuckled.
"W-Wait..."
Kid didn't stop though and came closer to bite on his neck while starting to unbutton Aesop's shirt. Added to that, Recluse suddenly came to sit on the end of the bed too, caressing his ass with one hand as he leaned a bit over him.
"This is quite unfair my dear, do you prefer him to me?" whispered Recluse.
"What the hell are you saying... Y-You're all the same person-..."
Aesop let out a moan when Kid pressed his knee even more against his crotch, his chest now fully naked for all of them to see.
"You're right, only I would be able to make you have such a lewd expression on your face." he smirked, "Though you still need to be punished for letting yourself be played with so easily..."
Recluse kissed the nape of his neck to leave a hickey and undid Aesop's pants to expose his ass, circling the tip of his finger around his hole before putting it in slowly inside, earning a gasp from the embalmer. Now Kid was busy sucking on his nipples and holding tightly his waist, however, having two men doing all of those things to him turned Aesop's mind upside down. He felt terribly embarrassed and his body was burning but one thing he knew was that he didn't want them to stop. Instead, he wanted all of their attention on him.
Seeing his lustful gaze, Lunar Phase also approached him, grasping his chin to make him look upwards to his face, the embalmer's view coming to meet with the sweet smile of the man.
"If you could take a glance at yourself... Looking so desperate like that, how can I resist too?" he breathed against his lips before finally sealing them with a deep kiss.
As Aesop and Lunar exchanged messy kisses, Recluse was still working on loosening his hole, now having put two other fingers and doing scissoring motions between his walls. The embalmer was in such a disheveled state due to the three men and his clothes were barely hanging on at this point.
Eventually, they were all left on the floor and Aesop was now sitting on top of the Phantom Thief who had taken off his pants.
"You should be ready after so long, right?"
The embalmer's cheeks flushed and he bit back a moan as he let himself sink down onto the man's cock, shaking a bit at first before slowly grinding his ass against his hips, both men grunting heatedly. Aesop arched back a bit and moaned louder due to Recluse nibbling on his right ear but his whimpers were muffled by Lunar who came to swirl his tongue around his, sometimes running it over his lips sensually to bite them softly.
"A-Ahh... Nnghh... E-Eli!" he stuttered.
"Which one?" asked Lunar before kissing him hungrily again.
"We can't know who you're talking to since we're all Eli." said Kid playfully while shoving his hips upwards all of a sudden, earning a gasp from the embalmer.
"M-More... I need more..."
"More? Well, you're the one who asked."
Recluse suddenly got up to get a bottle of lube from the embalmer's bedside table then took off his pants and poured a handful of the liquid in the palm of his hand, sliding it a few times on his shaft. The kiss with Lunar was broken and Aesop was suddenly made to lie down against Kid.
"W-Wait-, is it really going to fit-"
"There's only one way to know."
The brown-haired man smirked on these words and kneeled behind him, one hand on the embalmer's waist while the other slowly thrusted his dick inside his hole which was already filled by the other seer's cock.
"H-Ha-!" Aesop cried out with tears pricking his eyes, he felt like his walls were going to be torn apart this way but at the same time, he sensed a pleasure he had never experienced before which couldn't let him think straight anymore.
He buried his face in Kid's well built chest as Recluse started to pound against his prostate, his nails digging into the man's shoulders and desperate moans coming out from his mouth.
"F-Fuck..." panted Kid with both hands on his asscheeks to help him hit deeper.
"Aesop, look here..."
The embalmer lifted his face towards Lunar somehow, who was still smiling as sweetly as ever, but something deep inside him seemed to be screaming at him not to believe that harmless face.
"A-Ahh-..."
"You're not going to leave me out are you?" he said in a honeyed tone.
Aesop blushed harder as he understood his words and leaned slightly to the side to catch Lunar's penis in his hand, giving him a few rubs with it at first before swallowing it whole in one go. The seer huffed as the embalmer sucked on his dick so eagerly and he couldn't help but putting a hand on his head and starting to thrust his hips against his face, the latter almost choking on it but still swallowing everything as best as he could and playing with his balls at the same time.
"A-Aesop- You're doing so good-..."
All of them were a dirty and lustful mess, the sounds of skin slapping and the jerky breaths filling the room. The frantic thrusting from Recluse and Kid made the embalmer roll his eyes back, his own dick also getting frictions by being squeezed between his stomach and the one of the man below him. Meanwhile his lips were reddening because of Lunar face-fucking him mercilessly.
Aesop's mind was blurry but he could feel his climax coming and he also knew the three others wouldn't last long either. They all went at it for a bit more before finally stilling and filling his hole and mouth with their cum, the embalmer also coming against his stomach. His face was covered with tears and white liquid but he swallowed everything before letting go of Lunar's dick with a loud 'pop'.
Right after that, he started to go down from his high, his breath slowly coming back to a steadier pace. However, his body was so tired that he immediately fell asleep afterwards. His mind sinking into darkness.
Later on, the next morning, Aesop woke up next to only one Eli. He was surprised for a second and wondered if all of what happened was a dream but when he tried to move and froze due to a sharp pain in the lower part of his body, he knew it wasn't.
In the end, none of them ever knew the reason behind this weird phenomenon but that night they spent together will forever be etched in their memory.